Defining Religion: Methodology

Document Type : Qualitative Research

Author
Assistant professor of IHCS
Abstract
One of the most challenging issues raised in the theology and philosophy of religion is to define the concept of religion and its main components. This study aims to criticize and analyze the strengths and weaknesses of a definition of religion presented in "Reason and Religious Belief". The results show that the main strength of this definition is that it considers "beliefs", "actions", and "emotions", which are among the existential needs and abilities of humans. However, some weaknesses of this definition are as follows: 1- Difficulty in achieving common points between religions, 2- Ambiguous explanation of the main elements of the definition, 3- Inclusion beyond the definition, and 4- Inattention to specific and individual features in the definition of religion. It is noteworthy that one of the main challenges in defining the concept of religion is the necessity of a systemic approach. In addition, such an approach should be viewed based on methodological conditions.

Keywords

Subjects


1- Ashouri. D; 2010; Definitions and the concept of culture; Tehran, Agah Publication.
2- Andrew. E; Key concepts in cultural theory; 2009; Tehran, Office of Social Planning and Cultural Studies and Institute of Cultural and Social Studies, Ministry of Science, Research, and Technology.
3- Smart. N; 2010; Religious studies; translated by Seyyed Saeedreza Montazeri and Ahmad Shakranjad, Qom, Nashr-e Adyan.
4- Terence Stace. W; 2011; Religion and the modern mind; Translated by Ahmadreza Jalili; Tehran, Hekmat Publication.
5- Mircea. E; 1994; Religious studies; Translated by Bahauddin Khorramshahi; Tehran, Research Institute of Humanities and Cultural Studies.
6- Mircea. E; 1995; Culture and Religion; Translated by Bahauddin Khorramshahi; Tehran, Tarh-e No Publication.
7- Bagheri. K; 2010; Research approaches and methods in the philosophy of education; in cooperation with Narges Sajjadieh and Tayebeh Tavasoli; Tehran, Research Institute of Cultural and Social Studies, Ministry of Science, Research, and Technology.
8- Peterson. M., et al.; 1998; Reason and religious belief: an introduction to the philosophy of religion; Translated by Ahmad Naraghi and Ebrahim Soltani; Tehran, Tarh-e No Publication.
9- Proudfoot. W; 1998; Religious Experience; Translated by Abbas Yazdani, Qom, Taha Cultural Institute Publication.
10- Plant. R; 2007; Hegel: on Religion and Philosophy; Translated by Akbar Masoumbeigi, Tehran, Agah Publication.
11- Pahlevan. C; 2009; Culture and Civilization; Tehran, Nashre Ney.
12- Pirouz. G; 2008; Criticisms of New Critique based on a Systemic Approach; Scientific research journal of Faculty of Literature and Humanities of Mashhad University, No. 160.
13- Jorjani. M. S.; 1998; Definitions (A Dictionary of Islamic Education Terms); Translated by Hasan Seyed Arab and Sima Nourbakhsh, Tehran, Forouzan Publication.
14- Jalalimoghadam. M; 2000; An introduction to the sociology of religion and opinions of eminent sociologists of religion; Tehran, Nashre Markaz.
15- Javadi Amoli. A; 2002; Religious Studies; Qom, Asra Publishing Center.
16- Hosseini. S. H.; 1997; Religion in the context of different views; Marefat Journal. No 20.
17- Khorasani. A; 2008; Interdisciplinary discourse of knowledge: typology and theoretical foundations of policies for action in higher education; Tehran, Research Institute of Cultural and Social Studies, Ministry of Science, Research, and Technology.
18- Khandan. S. A.; 2000; Applied logic; Tehran and Qom, Organization for Researching and Composing University Textbooks in the Humanities and Taha Cultural Institute.
19- Khansari. M; 1997; Dictionary of logical terms: including French and English; Tehran, Research Institute of Humanities and Cultural Studies.
20- Danesh. J; 2007; Sociology of Religion; Tehran, Maaref Publication.
21- Davari. R; 2000; About Science; Tehran, Hermes Publication.
22- Davari Ardakani. R; 2011; Art and Truth: Wittgenstein, a language thinker; Tehran, Rasta Publication.
23- Dilthey. W; 2004; The Essence of Philosophy; Translated by Hassan Rahmani, Qom, Mofid University Publication.
24- Salarifar. M. R., Azerbaijani. M, Rahiminejad. A; 2005; Theoretical foundations of religious scales; proceedings of a conference on theoretical foundations and psychometrics of religious scales; Qom and Tehran, Publishing Center of Seminary and University Research Institute and Office of National Plans, Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance.
25- Shojaei Zand. A. R.; 2009; Sociology of Religion (1): About the Topic; Tehran, Nashre Ney.
26- Saliba. J; 1991; Dictionary of philosophy and social sciences; Translated by Kazem Bargnisi and Sadegh Sajjadi, Tehran, publishing company.
27- Faramarz Qaramelki. A; 2004; Principles and techniques of research for religious studies; Qom, Qom Theological Seminary Management Center Publication.
28- Farshad. M; 1989; Iranian mysticism and systemic worldview; Tehran, Balkh Publication.
29- Farshad. M; 1983; Systemic approach; Tehran, Amir Kabir Publishing Institute.
30- Grayling. A. C.; 2009; Wittgenstein; Translated by Abolfazl Haghiri, Tehran, Basirt Publication.
31- Mojtahedi. K; 2004; Phenomenology of soul according to Hegel's opinions: A overview of Genesis and Structure of Hegel's Phenomenology of Spirit written by Jean Hyppolite; Tehran, Scientific, and Cultural Publishing Company.
32- Morin. E; 2000; An introduction to complex thinking; Translated by Afshin Jahandideh, Tehran, Nashre Ney.
33- Morin. E; 2008; Complex thinking and learning methods in the planetary era; Institute of Cultural and Social Studies, Ministry of Science, Research, and Technology.
34- Naas. J; 1993; A comprehensive history of religions; Translated by Aliasghar Hekmat, Tehran, Islamic Revolution Publication and Education Center.
35- Naraghi. A; 1999; A Treaties on the Knowledge of Religion: An analysis model of Iman Ebrahimi; Tehran, Tarhe No.
36- Willem. J. P.; 1998; Sociology of religions; Translated by Dr. Abdolrahim Govahi, Tehran, Tebyan Publishing Cultural Institute.
37- Hospers. J; 2000; An Introduction to Philosophical Analysis; Translated by Musa Akrami, Tehran, Tarhe No Publication.
38- Hamilton. M; 2008; Sociology of Religion; Translated by Mohsen Salasi, Tehran, Sales Publication.
39- Hick. J; 1997; Philosophy of Religion; Translated by Behzad Saleki, Tehran, Al-Hadi International Publication.
40- Hume. R. E.; 1993; The World's Living Religions; Translated by Dr. Abdolrahim Govahi, Tehran, Tehran, Islamic Culture Publishing Office.
41- Hume. D; 2008; The Natural History of Religion; Translated by Hamid Enayat, Tehran, Kharazmi Publication.