Historical Evolution of Educational Research Methodology in Iran

Authors
Ali Nouri 1
Mahmoud Mehrmohammadi 2
Mohamad Sharif Taherpour 3
Ali Asghar Khallaghi 4
1 Associate Professor of Curriculum Studies, Malayer University, Iran
2 Professor of Curriculum Studies in Tarbiat Modares University(TMU)
3 3Assistant Professor of Philosophy of Education, Malayer University, Iran.
4 4Assistant Professor of Education, Shahid Rajaee Teacher Training University, Iran.
Abstract
This study focuses on the significant lines of development characterizing the history of educational research methodology in Iran. A “historical case study” employed to collect, verify, and synthesize evidence about the same as such appeared in the Quarterly Journal of Education. The results indicated that the educational research in Iran has experienced five, distinct yet, overlapping and simultaneously operating historical moments. The first is the pre-methodology (1919- 1985) stage, during which scholars carried out their investigations without a distinct systematic scientific method. The second (1985- 1994) is a period of rising quantitative approach, during which quantitative methods were becoming central in the education field. The third (1995- 2004) is characterized by insistence on the monopoly of quantitative, during which educational and other social science researchers relied primarily on quantitative methods and statistical inference understood as a means to test the proposed hypotheses. The fourth (2005–2014), is a replacement stage started with the wave of qualitative taking over the traditional and provoked the appearance of a new hegemony. The concern for quality stage (2015-2019) is the fifth when the threat of losing credibility and leaving a relativistic impression were considered by members of the research community. It is concluded that Iran’s educational research urgently requires mobilized and rationalized methodological pluralism with the ultimate goal of improving on existing pedagogical practices.

Keywords

Subjects

[1] Ashraf, A., (1997). General survey of modern education, Encyclopedia Iranica, Online Edition. Available at http://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/education-vii-general-survey-of-modern-education (Accessed 24 March 2013).
[2] Ayati, A.M., (1975). ‘Translation Movement’. Education Monthly, 44 (4), 228-236.
[3] Ayman, I., (1974). Educational Innovation in Iran. The UNESCO Press, Paris, France.
[4] Clawson, P. & Rubin, M., (2005). Eternal Iran Continuity and Chaos. Palgrave Macmillan, UK.
[5] Eisner, E.W., (1994). The Educational Imagination (3rd Edition). Macmillan College Publishing Company: New York.
[6] Fardanesh, H., (2009). ‘Theoretical and Practical Developments of Instructional Technology in Iran in the Past Century’. Quarterly Journal of Education, 24 (4), 51- 82.
[7] Yadegarzadeh, G. & Fatemi, A., (2017). ‘Evaluation of Educational Scientific Articles with the Purpose of Identifying Common Statistical Errors’. Journal of Instruction and Evaluation, 11(41), 135-154.
[8] Hekmat, A.A., (1956). ‘Memories of the History of the Journal of Education’. Education Monthly, 27(4), 991-997.
[9] Higher Council of Educational Planning. (2016). The Curriculum for B.A in Education Studies. Iran Ministry of Research Science and Technology.
[10] Jafari Dehaghi, M., (2005). ‘Establishing Iranian Scientific Schools during the Ancient Time and its Impact on the Transfer of Iranian Culture and Knowledge’. Interdisciplinary Journal of the Faculty of Literature and Humanities (Chamran University of Ahvaz), 2, 43-64.
[11] Johnson, R.B. & Onwuegbuzie, A.J., (2004). ‘Mixed Methods Research: A Research Paradigm Whose Time has Come’. Educational Researcher, 33(7), 14-26.
[12] Khallaghi, A. A., (2009). ‘Research Transition in Education’. Educational Research Letters, 106 & 107, 12-14.
[13] Khallaghi, A.A., (1989). How Can We Organize Research in Vocational Education and Training? Office of Research and planning for vocational education and training, Ministry of Education, Tehran, Iran
[14] Khallaghi, A.A., (2001). ‘An Analytical Study of the Process of Changing the Education System of Iran in Two Decades after the Victory of the Islamic Revolution and the Future Perspective’. Presented at the 7th Conference of the Iranian Educational Research Association, May 27th. 2001, Tehran, Iran.
[15] Khodabandelou, R., Aleebrahim, N., Amoozegar, A. & Mehran, G., (2019). ‘Revisiting Three Decades of Educational Research in Iran: A Bibliometric Analysis’. Iranian Journal of Comparative Education, 2(1), 1-21.
[16] Kim, C.U., (2003). ‘At the Age of Complexities: Tales of Teaching Qualitative Research in South Korea’. The Collection of Papers to the First World Curriculum Studies Conference, 151 – 163.
[17] Krull, E., (2007). ‘Promoting Teacher Education Curricula by Using Methods of Historical Research: Estonian Case’. Trames, 11(61/56), 1, 69–85.
[18] Lotfabadi, H., (2009). ‘Educational Psychology in Iran and the West: Past, Present, and the Future’. Quarterly Journal of Education, 24 (4), 125- 172.
[19] Lotfabadi, H., Nowroozi V. & Hosseini. (2007). ‘Investigating the Teaching of Research Methodology in Psychology and Education in Iran’. Review Quarterly Journal of Educational Innovations, 6 (21), 109- 140.
[20] Mehrmohammadi, M., (2007). ‘Investigation of Methodological Preferences of Educational Researchers in Iran’. Review Quarterly Journal of Educational Innovations, 6 (21), 77- 108.
[21] Mehrmohammadi, M., (2012). ‘Methodological Pluralism: Decline of Positivism or Demise of Actuality?’ Foundations of Education, 9(1), 27-46.
[22] Mosapoor, N., (2009). ‘Curriculum Planning in Contemporary Iran’. Quarterly Journal of Education, 24 (4), 83- 124.
[23] Mozaffarmagham, A., (2009). ‘Documents of Correspondence between Mirza Hasan Roshdieh, Founder of Modern Schools, and the National Consultative Assembly’. Payame Baharestan, 1, (3), 503-526.
[24] Nazeri, M., (2004). ‘Translation of Islamic Texts in Europe during the 12th and 13th Centuries AD’. Islamic History Magazine, 19, 127-152.
[25] Nouri, A. & Etemadizadeh, H., (2018). ‘Teachers’ Knowledge of and Attitudes towards Educational Research’. Research Project, Malayer University.
[26] Nouri, A., (2014). Quarterly Journal of Education. Iranian Encyclopedia of Curriculum Studies.
[27] Paya. A., (2007). ‘Critical Rationalism and Situational Logic: An Effective Approach to Methodology of Educational Research’. Review Quarterly Journal of Educational Innovations, 6 (21), 11- 48.
[28] Radmanesh, A-M., (2005). ‘The Beginning and End of the Academy of Gondishapur’. Interdisciplinary Journal of the Faculty of Literature and Humanities (Shahid Chamran University of Ahvaz), 2, 69-88.
[29] Safi, A., (1992). Research on Research Carried out at the Ministry of Education and the Application of the Results in the Decision Making of Top Management. Research Council of the Ministry of Education, Tehran, Iran.
[30] Secretariat of Planning and Production Curriculum. (2012). National Curriculum of the Islamic Republic of Iran. Tehran: Research and Planning Organization.
[31] Sha'baani Varaki, B., (2005). ‘The Quality of Educational Research in Iran: A Critique of Methodology’. Quarterly Journal of Education, 22 (1), 10 – 35.
[32] Shekari-Nayyeri, J. & Tavousi, M., (2005). ‘History of Scientific, Educational and Religious Centers in Ancient Iran’. Interdisciplinary Journal of the Faculty of Literature and Humanities (Shahid Chamran University of Ahvaz), 2, 99-132.
[33] Tashakkori, A. & Teddlie, E., (Eds). (2003). Handbook of Mixed Methods in Social and Behavioral Research. Thousand Oaks, CA, Sage.
[34] Vahidnia, S., (1971). ‘The History of Iranian Literature Journals’. Armaghan, 40 (2), 138-142. [35] Wesner, B., (1994). ‘The Value of Historical Research’. Parks and Recreation, 29(2), 30-34.
[36] Widdersheim, M.M., (2018). ‘Historical Case Study: A Research Strategy for Diachronic Analysis’. Library and Information Science Research 40, 44–152.
[37] Williams, C., (2007). ‘Research Methods’. Journal of Business & Economic Research, 5 (3), 65-72.
[38] World Bank. (2009). ‘Education and the World Bank’. Retrieved September 6, 2009, available at www.worldbank.org/education
The International Journal of Humanities
Volume 27, Issue 4
Autumn 2020
Pages 21-31